Should I Replace My Gutters When Replacing My Roof?
Replacing your roof is one of the most important investments you’ll make in your home. But as you review bids, materials, and timelines, you might be asking: Should I replace my gutters when replacing my roof? The answer isn’t always black and white, but in many cases, the smartest move is yes — and here’s why.
At Litespeed Construction, Asheville’s trusted roofing contractor, we’ve seen firsthand how old or mismatched gutters can undermine even the best new roof installations. In this article, we’ll break down the top reasons to replace your gutters, when it makes sense to keep them, and how it impacts your home’s longevity, safety, and resale value.
Key Takeaways
💡Replacing Gutters With Your Roof Saves Time & Money
💡Old or Damaged Gutters Can Undermine a New Roof
💡Many Homeowners Can File Insurance Claims for Both
💡Replacing Both Increases Home Value and Curb Appeal
Why Gutters Matter for Your Roof
Gutters do much more than just redirect rainwater. They protect your roof, siding, foundation, landscaping, and structural integrity. A roof without a properly functioning gutter system is exposed to moisture intrusion, mold, and erosion — all major problems for homeowners.
According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), clogged or broken gutters are one of the top five causes of water damage to homes in North America.
When you install a new roof, it’s the perfect opportunity to assess whether your gutters are still doing their job.
When Should I Replace My Gutters?
Ask yourself the following:
- Are your gutters older than 15 years?
- Do they show visible sagging, rust, or holes?
- Do you see overflowing water during rain?
- Have your gutters been damaged by hail, wind, or snow?
If you answered yes to any of these questions, it may be more cost-effective to replace your gutters while replacing the roof rather than patching them later.
Pro Tip:
A new roof installation often requires adjusting or temporarily removing the gutters — especially with metal roofs or architectural shingles. Reinstalling failing gutters on a new roof is like putting old tires on a brand-new car.
Benefits of Replacing Gutters With a New Roof
Here’s why combining gutter and roof replacement makes sense:
1. Cost Efficiency
Asheville, NC Roofers are already on-site with ladders, scaffolding, and crew. Adding gutter replacement minimizes labor duplication and reduces overall project costs by 10%–20% compared to separate jobs.
2. Seamless Integration
Proper flashing, drip edges, and gutter alignment are easier to install when roofing and gutters are done at the same time, preventing leaks and water backup.
3. Curb Appeal & Resale Value
According to Remodeling Magazine’s Cost vs. Value Report, roofing and gutter replacement projects have some of the highest ROI in home improvements — averaging 68.2% resale value recovery.
4. Material Matching
Color-matching new roof shingles with updated gutters enhances your home’s appearance and increases buyer appeal.
Warning Signs That It’s Time to Replace Gutters
| Problem | Risk to Roof | Visible Sign |
|---|---|---|
| Cracks, Holes, or Rust | Water infiltration under shingles | Rust spots, peeling paint |
| Sagging Gutters | Improper drainage | Pulling away from fascia |
| Frequent Clogs | Overflow, ice dams | Water spilling over during rain |
| Improper Pitch | Standing water on roof edges | Staining on siding or trim |
If you notice these issues during your roofing consultation, it’s a strong signal that now is the time to replace your gutters.
Costs, Savings & Insurance Considerations
- Gutter Replacement Cost: A full gutter system replacement averages between $1,200 – $2,400 for a typical home.
- Roof + Gutter Combined Package: Often saves homeowners up to 15% when done together.
- Insurance Claims: If your roof was damaged by hail or storms (and covered by insurance), gutters are often included under the same claim. Litespeed Construction will assist with photo documentation and insurance coordination.
According to the FEMA Mitigation Assessment Team, improperly managed water from roofs causes thousands of dollars in avoidable damage annually, which insurance providers are starting to scrutinize more closely.
What Government Experts Say
- EPA: Improper water drainage contributes to foundation erosion and basement flooding. (Source: EPA Water Management Guidelines)
- HUD: Regular gutter maintenance and replacement are vital for long-term roof and wall integrity.
- NOAA & FEMA: Severe storms have increased in frequency and intensity, increasing the need for updated roofing and gutter protection.
Web Ratings & Consumer Insights
When scheduling a professional roof inspection in North Carolina, it’s essential to research a company’s reputation before making a decision. Platforms like Google Reviews, Angi (formerly Angie’s List), and HomeAdvisor offer authentic feedback from local homeowners and can give you a clear picture of each contractor’s reliability and workmanship. Prioritize roofing contractors with consistently high ratings, detailed positive reviews, and proven experience working with roofs suited for North Carolina’s unique climate conditions, including heavy rain, humidity, and seasonal storms.
FAQs about Roof Inspections in North Carolina
No, but it’s highly recommended if your gutters are older, damaged, or leaking.
Not if done correctly. In fact, installing gutters with your new roof prevents damage from reinstalling old units.
Standard aluminum gutters last 15–20 years, while copper can last 50+ years.
Yes, hail can dent, bend, and weaken gutters, making them prone to overflow.
If they were damaged by a storm, yes — and Litespeed Construction helps handle the claim.
Seamless aluminum, copper, and galvanized steel are popular options depending on your climate and budget.
Yes, especially when paired with a new roof. It signals full exterior protection to buyers.
Neutral tones like black, white, or bronze often pair well with architectural shingles.
Temporary fixes don’t address core drainage issues. Full replacement is usually more reliable long-term.
Litespeed Construction offers same-week roof and gutter inspections for homeowners in Asheville and surrounding areas.
Final Thoughts From Litespeed Construction
At Litespeed Construction, we believe homeowners deserve the best information and the best protection. When you ask yourself, “Should I replace my gutters when replacing my roof?” — our answer is simple:
Yes, if you want full protection, long-term savings, and maximum home value.
Our Asheville-based team is here to help you inspect, plan, and even work with your insurance company so you can feel confident about your roofing and gutter investment.
📍 Proudly Serving: Asheville, Edneyville, Waynesville, Black Mountain, Arden, and surrounding Western NC.
